Rule 11: Challenging Pleading Requirements in the Eleventh Circuit

Image related with this article: Rule 11: Challenging Pleading Requirements in the Eleventh Circuit
In a case that addresses the requirements for a proper pleading, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit recently heard an appeal from the judgment of the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Georgia.

In a case that addresses the requirements for a proper pleading, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit recently heard an appeal from the judgment of the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Georgia. This case, US v. Jayson E. Wright, delves into the pleading procedure under Rule 11 of the Federal Rules of Evidence, while also defining the elements of a criminal charge under 18 U.S.C. §2251(a) in the process.

On August 17, 2020, Wright’s daughter alleged that her parents were sexually abusing her, causing a family friend to alert the police. The police searched Wright’s home, finding many images and videos containing child pornography, with some explicitly featuring Wright’s daughter. Wright pleaded guilty to one count of producing child pornography, as well as a more specific charge for the production of such content by a parent or legal guardian. Both charges were brought under 18 U.S.C. §2251, which criminalizes the sexual exploitation of children. §2251(a) governs the production of child pornography broadly, while §2251(b) includes the additional element of parental involvement in the production of the pornography. As a result of his guilty plea, Wright was sentenced to 720 months’ imprisonment.

Despite having pleaded guilty, Wright appealed his conviction, asserting that the district court violated Rule 11 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure by allowing him to plead guilty to the charge under §2251(a). Rule 11 codifies the proper procedure for plea agreements for criminal charges. Wright raised two key issues under Rule 11, with both arguments centering around the notion that the district court should not have taken his guilty plea. First, Wright argued there was not an adequate factual basis to support his plea. Additionally, Wright contended that §2251(a) and (e) require that the minor voluntarily participated in the sexual act to sustain his conviction. The district court never mentioned such a requirement, which Wright characterized as a failure to explain the nature of his charge, causing him to plead guilty when he otherwise would not.

To answer these questions, the Eleventh Circuit first clarified Wright’s burden on this appeal, noting that he must establish the existence of a plain or obvious error. Wright must also show that the error was prejudicial to a degree that affected his substantial rights and seriously affected the fairness or integrity of the judicial proceedings. Relying on precedent to determine the obviousness of the alleged error, the Court cited its own recent decision rejecting a volitional participation requirement for §2251(a) charges. In that decision, the Eleventh Circuit held that the multitude of verbs used within the statute allows §2251(a) to cover a broad range of criminal conduct, including situations where the minor is both passively and actively involved. Extending this ruling to the case at hand, the Court held that, because §2251(a) does not require the willing participation the minor, the district court was not required to make such a factual showing under Rule 11(b)(3), nor was it within the nature of the charge. Therefore, the district court did not err in accepting Wright’s plea or failing to disclose such a requirement.

US v. Jayson E. Wright demonstrates the appropriate pleading procedure under Rule 11. By relying on the Court’s own precedent in defining the limits of §2251(a), the Eleventh Circuit nullified the alleged deficiencies in Wright’s charges, holding that the district court was not required to make any showings or explanations related to volitional participation under Rule 11. Although the Court ultimately affirmed the plea agreement, finding no plain error in the district court’s actions, the Eleventh Circuit’s willingness to hear an appeal from a voluntary guilty plea serves as a modest reinforcement to the rights of the accused.

articles

Blogs

1 / 44
Murder Charges in Alabama: Penalties and Defenses

Murder Charges in Alabama: Penalties and Defenses

In Alabama, murder is a Class A felony punishable by 10 years to life in prison. Learn the law, the difference from capital murder, and possible defenses.

read articles
Manslaughter in Alabama: Understanding the Law and Penalties

Manslaughter in Alabama: Understanding the Law and Penalties

In Alabama, manslaughter is a serious felony punishable by 2 to 20 years in prison. Learn how it differs from murder, possible defenses, and why legal help is critical.

read articles
Child Pornography Charges in Alabama: Penalties and Defenses

Child Pornography Charges in Alabama: Penalties and Defenses

In Alabama, child pornography charges carry harsh penalties including prison and mandatory sex offender registration. Learn the law, possible defenses, and why you need experienced legal help.

read articles
Sodomy Charges in Alabama: Penalties and Defenses

Sodomy Charges in Alabama: Penalties and Defenses

In Alabama, sodomy is a serious sex crime punishable by decades in prison and mandatory sex offender registration. Learn the law, penalties, and possible defenses.

read articles
First Degree Burglary in Alabama: Penalties and Defenses

First Degree Burglary in Alabama: Penalties and Defenses

In Alabama, first degree burglary is a Class A felony punishable by 10 years to life in prison. Learn the legal definition, penalties, and possible defenses.

read articles
First Degree Robbery in Alabama: Penalties and Defenses

First Degree Robbery in Alabama: Penalties and Defenses

In Alabama, first degree robbery is a Class A felony punishable by 10 years to life in prison. Learn the law, possible defenses, and why immediate legal help is essential.

read articles
Sex Trafficking Charges in Alabama: Penalties, Defenses, and What to Expect

Sex Trafficking Charges in Alabama: Penalties, Defenses, and What to Expect

In Alabama, sex trafficking is a Class A felony punishable by 10 years to life in prison. Learn what the law says, possible defenses, and why hiring an experienced criminal defense lawyer is critical.

read articles
Drug Trafficking in Alabama: Meth, Fentanyl, Heroin, and Cocaine

Drug Trafficking in Alabama: Meth, Fentanyl, Heroin, and Cocaine

In Alabama, drug trafficking involving meth, fentanyl, heroin, or cocaine is a Class A felony with mandatory prison sentences. Learn the penalties, possible defenses, and why quick legal help is essential.

read articles
Shooting Into an Occupied Vehicle or Dwelling in Alabama: A Class ‘A’ Felony

Shooting Into an Occupied Vehicle or Dwelling in Alabama: A Class ‘A’ Felony

In Alabama, shooting into an occupied vehicle or dwelling is a Class A felony punishable by 10 years to life in prison. Learn what the law says, possible defenses, and why you need immediate legal representation.

read articles
Class ‘A’ Felonies in Alabama: Murder, Homicide, and Violent Crimes

Class ‘A’ Felonies in Alabama: Murder, Homicide, and Violent Crimes

Charged with a Class A felony in Alabama? Learn what Class A felonies are, the penalties you could face, and why having an experienced criminal defense lawyer is critical. Understand the law, possible defenses, and what to do if you or a loved one is accused of a serious violent crime.

read articles
Terminix v. Turner: When Can You Be Forced to Arbitrate

Terminix v. Turner: When Can You Be Forced to Arbitrate

Learn when Alabama courts will enforce mandatory arbitration clauses in service agreements, as explained in Terminix v. Turner. Discover how broad arbitration provisions can limit your right to sue, and what this means for consumers and businesses.

read articles
How Far Away is Medical Cannabis in Alabama

How Far Away is Medical Cannabis in Alabama

Find out why medical cannabis is still unavailable in Alabama despite being legalized in 2021. This article explains the regulatory delays, licensing issues, and what needs to happen before patients can finally access medical cannabis in the state.

read articles
How to Challenge a Property Value Evaluation

How to Challenge a Property Value Evaluation

Learn how to challenge a property value evaluation in Alabama, including the legal steps and statutory requirements outlined by the Alabama Supreme Court in Scott v. Alabama Department of Revenue. Protect your home by understanding your rights and the appeal process.

read articles
How To Get A Pardon in Alabama: The Story of a Former Client

How To Get A Pardon in Alabama: The Story of a Former Client

Discover how a full pardon can give you a fresh start in Alabama, as shown by a real client’s journey from a troubled past to a successful future. Learn about the pardon process, eligibility, and how Joe Ingram Law helps clients clear old convictions and reclaim their lives.

read articles
The Interplay Between Regular Place of Abode Service of Process

The Interplay Between Regular Place of Abode Service of Process

Learn how Alabama courts define “regular place of abode” for service of process, and why using an official address can be sufficient to uphold a lawsuit’s outcome—even if the defendant claims they never received notice. Understand the recent Lewis v. Ojano-Bracco decision and what it means for default judgments.

read articles
Coach Tuberville: Governor or Outsider?

Coach Tuberville: Governor or Outsider?

Explore the legal and political questions surrounding Senator Tommy Tuberville’s 2026 bid for Alabama governor. This article examines Alabama’s residency requirements, the “carpetbagger” debate, and why Tuberville’s candidacy is likely to be decided in court.

read articles
What Gregory Hunt’s Death Says About Capital Punishment in Alabama

What Gregory Hunt’s Death Says About Capital Punishment in Alabama

Gregory Hunt’s execution in Alabama highlights major issues in the state’s capital punishment system, including the use of nitrogen gas, lengthy death row waits, and non-unanimous jury verdicts. Learn what his case reveals about the realities and controversies of the death penalty in Alabama.

read articles
Is a Child Abducted When a Parent Flees the State Before Divorce is Filed?

Is a Child Abducted When a Parent Flees the State Before Divorce is Filed?

Find out how Alabama courts define child abduction when a parent relocates with a child before divorce is filed. This article examines the recent Stanford v. Anaya decision and explains what counts as wrongful removal or retention under Alabama law.

read articles
Adams v. Atkinson: How the Alabama Supreme Court Reviews Contracts

Adams v. Atkinson: How the Alabama Supreme Court Reviews Contracts

Learn how the Alabama Supreme Court interprets contract language in Adams v. Atkinson, focusing on the legal meaning of "hold harmless" versus "indemnify." This decision provides guidance for resolving contract disputes and clarifies how courts approach ambiguous terms.

read articles
Parole In Alabama: How the Proposed Parole Guidelines May Affect You

Parole In Alabama: How the Proposed Parole Guidelines May Affect You

Learn how Alabama’s proposed parole guidelines may impact parole hearings and pardon rates. This article explains the new scoring system, what it means for inmates and their families, and how it could affect your loved one’s chance for early release.

read articles
United States v. Zayas: The Bank Secrecy Act

United States v. Zayas: The Bank Secrecy Act

Explore the United States v. Zayas decision and learn how structuring financial transactions to evade the Bank Secrecy Act’s $10,000 reporting threshold can lead to federal criminal charges. Understand the standards courts use to determine willful evasion under this law.

read articles
Can You Go to Jail for Not Paying Child Support?

Can You Go to Jail for Not Paying Child Support?

Find out if you can go to jail for not paying child support in Alabama. Learn how contempt of court works, what jail time may result, and what recent court cases reveal about your legal risks when child support payments are missed.

read articles
J.M.M v. State: When Life in Prison is Deserved

J.M.M v. State: When Life in Prison is Deserved

Discover why the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals upheld life sentences for aggravated child abuse in the case of J.M.M. v. State. Learn how courts determine when the maximum penalty is appropriate for child abuse cases involving serious physical injury.

read articles
What is and What Is not First-Degree Assault

What is and What Is not First-Degree Assault

Learn what legally qualifies as first-degree assault in Alabama, and what does not, based on recent appellate court decisions. This article explains the key elements of first-degree assault and why not all injuries involving weapons meet the legal standard for serious physical injury.

read articles
Whistleblower Lawsuits: How You Can Be a Hero & Make Millions

Whistleblower Lawsuits: How You Can Be a Hero & Make Millions

Discover how whistleblowers can expose government fraud under the False Claims Act and potentially earn millions in rewards. Learn your rights, legal options, and how to take action today.

read articles
Mulkey v. State: Appealing the Death Penalty

Mulkey v. State: Appealing the Death Penalty

Learn how Alabama appellate courts review death penalty cases and plain error claims. Mulkey v. State shows how appellate safeguards protect defendants’ rights in capital murder appeals.

read articles
Pig-Butchering: A Modern Bank Robbery

Pig-Butchering: A Modern Bank Robbery

Discover how a sophisticated "pig butchering" scam orchestrated by a Malaysian crime syndicate led to a $65 million digital heist. Learn about legal remedies, victim rights, and landmark court cases offering hope for recovering stolen cryptocurrency.

read articles
Sex Offender Restrictions: Can They Be Unconstitutional

Sex Offender Restrictions: Can They Be Unconstitutional

The Eleventh Circuit ruled a key Alabama sex offender statute unconstitutional, affirming a father’s right to live with his child. Learn how criminal appeals can protect your rights.

read articles
Juvenile Justice? The case of K.A v. State of Alabama

Juvenile Justice? The case of K.A v. State of Alabama

A look into Alabama’s juvenile justice system through the case of K.A.—examining Miranda rights, sentencing, and the court’s duty to balance justice and rehabilitation.

read articles
The Difficulties of Maintaining a Summary Judgment

The Difficulties of Maintaining a Summary Judgment

Learn how a seemingly simple legal win through summary judgment was reversed in Alonso v. Alpha Phi due to unresolved factual disputes and procedural missteps.

read articles
 The Limitations on Criminal Confessions

The Limitations on Criminal Confessions

Learn how the Corpus Delicti rule protects your rights in DUI and drug confession cases. Joe Ingram Law explains how improper police procedures can render a confession inadmissible—and help you beat your charge.

read articles
Taylor v. Humpries: A Failure of Equity and Common Sense.

Taylor v. Humpries: A Failure of Equity and Common Sense.

Explore Taylor v. Humphries, a controversial Alabama court case where a disabled U.S. citizen was denied a state ID due to bureaucratic barriers. This article examines how rigid legal formalism can undermine equity, common sense, and public trust in the justice system.

read articles
Child Custody Across State Lines

Child Custody Across State Lines

Learn how child custody jurisdiction works across state lines under the UCCJEA. Discover how Alabama courts can retain authority even after one parent relocates, and what legal rights you have when custody orders are challenged in another state.

read articles
Custodial Sexual Misconduct and The Sex Offender Registry

Custodial Sexual Misconduct and The Sex Offender Registry

Charged with custodial sexual misconduct in Alabama? Learn how a conviction can put you on the sex offender registry, what recent court cases mean for your future, and why legal reform is urgently needed.

read articles
Enforcing Arbitration Agreements Against a Third Party

Enforcing Arbitration Agreements Against a Third Party

Learn how Alabama law treats arbitration agreements in estate litigation. Discover when third parties—like executors—can be bound by a decedent’s arbitration clause.

read articles
When Can A Police Officer Use Deadly Force?

When Can A Police Officer Use Deadly Force?

Learn when a police officer can legally use deadly force under the Fourth Amendment. Explore key court rulings and constitutional standards in this high-profile Eleventh Circuit case.

read articles
Clearing Your Record in Alabama: What You Need to Know About Expungement

Clearing Your Record in Alabama: What You Need to Know About Expungement

Learn how to expunge a criminal record in Alabama. Discover eligibility rules, filing steps, costs, and how expungement can give you a fresh start. Get expert legal help.

read articles
HB247 Lulu’s Law: Irrational, But Beautiful

HB247 Lulu’s Law: Irrational, But Beautiful

Discover how Alabama’s Lulu’s Law established a shark attack monitoring and emergency alert system for the state’s coastal counties. Learn why this unique legislation, inspired by community advocacy after a tragic incident, reflects the power of local voices in shaping state policy. Explore the case’s impact, legislative background, and what it means for public safety on Alabama beaches.

read articles
Right to Counsel: When has this right been breached?

Right to Counsel: When has this right been breached?

Understand when the constitutional right to counsel applies in criminal cases. Learn from the recent Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals decision in Russell v. State about the critical stages where legal representation is required.

read articles
Can Prison Sentence Reductions Cross State Lines

Can Prison Sentence Reductions Cross State Lines

Discover whether prison sentence reductions can transfer across state lines. Learn about a key 2025 Alabama case that clarifies how correctional incentives apply when inmates move between states.

read articles
When is evidence sufficient to revoke probation?

When is evidence sufficient to revoke probation?

Learn when evidence is sufficient to revoke probation, based on a key 2025 Alabama court ruling. Understand the role of hearsay, probation violations, and legal standards in probation revocation cases.

read articles
Restitution and Evidence: When Is There Enough Evidence For Restitution

Restitution and Evidence: When Is There Enough Evidence For Restitution

Learn when restitution orders are legally valid under Alabama law. Discover why evidence and a proper hearing are essential before courts can require repayment to victims in criminal cases.

read articles
Understanding Cybercrime Charges and Digital Defense Strategies

Understanding Cybercrime Charges and Digital Defense Strategies

Facing cybercrime allegations? Learn the types of cybercrime charges, potential penalties, and how Joe Ingram Law LLC builds strong digital defense strategies. Summary Description: Explore how Joe Ingram Law LLC defends against cybercrime allegations with expert knowledge of digital forensics, hacking laws, identity theft, and data breaches.

read articles
The Interplay Between Plea Agreements and Aggravating Factors

The Interplay Between Plea Agreements and Aggravating Factors

Attorney Teresa Darwin Phillips pleaded guilty to theft, deception, and elder exploitation in Alabama. Learn how her failure to pay restitution impacted her sentencing and why the court upheld late notice of aggravating factors.

read articles

schedule a consultation

Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo

Your path to get the right compensation starts here.