Custodial Sexual Misconduct and The Sex Offender Registry

Image related with this article: Custodial Sexual Misconduct and The Sex Offender Registry
Charged with custodial sexual misconduct in Alabama? Learn how a conviction can put you on the sex offender registry, what recent court cases mean for your future, and why legal reform is urgently needed.

You made a mistake, one that started with a feeling and ended in a legal nightmare. While working as a correctional officer, you fell for an inmate. At first, it seemed harmless, just conversations that lingered too long, glances that meant more than they should have. But before you knew it, boundaries had been crossed. You told yourself it was real, that the connection meant something. But eventually, it became painfully clear: he was using you.

As the relationship progressed, you discovered that his affection wasn’t genuine. He was manipulating you as part of a plan to escape. You were already in too deep, but you couldn’t ignore what was happening. You made the difficult choice to report it to your supervisor. You knew there would be consequences for your career, your reputation, and even your freedom. But you also knew it was the right thing to do. You couldn’t let him try the same thing with someone else. The court recognized your cooperation and showed some leniency. You were offered a plea deal: plead guilty and avoid prison time. Weighing your options, you took the deal. But at the time, you didn’t fully understand the consequences of your guilty plea.

Only later did you realize that the plea required you to register as a sex offender. That’s when reality hit you, you’re now listed on the same registry as child predators and serial offenders. You’re subject to the same restrictions. You think: how can this be justice? How can your actions, misguided as they were, be equated under the law with the worst kind of offenders? It feels like a mistake, like the system didn’t account for context, for intent, for the gray areas of your situation. Still in disbelief, you turn to your lawyer and ask the question that keeps you up at night: Is this a mistake?

On April 25, 2025, the Alabama Supreme Court decided a similar case arising out of St. Clair County, Alabama. In Matthews v. State, the Court held that Briana Marquise Matthews, a correctional officer charged with custodial sexual misconduct, was required to register as a sex offender in Alabama. In that case, Matthews “asked to be relieved from the reporting requirements because her… convictions were based on consensual sexual encounters with an adult inmate[.] [S]he had no prior convictions or other criminal charges[.] [S]he did not have a propensity to reoffend, and she was not a danger to society.” Matthews v. State, No. SC-2024-0447, 2025 WL 1198358, at *1 (Ala. Apr. 25, 2025). Therefore, she argued that she should not be subject to registration as a sex offender. Id.

The Supreme Court of Alabama rejected this argument, finding that it did not conform with Alabama law. Section 15-20A-24 of the Alabama Code provides that individuals may seek relief from registering as a sex offender “if the sex offender proves by clear and convincing evidence that he or she satisfies, among other criteria.” Ala. Code § 15-20A-24; Matthews v. State, WL 1198358, at *4. However, the “among other criteria” language refers to a list of eligible offenses, “none of which included Matthews's custodial-sexual-misconduct convictions.” Matthews v. State, WL 1198358, at *5.

In response, Matthews argued that the State considered only “sexual misconduct”, which was included in the list of eligible offenses—and not custodial sexual misconduct. Therefore since her crime is similar she should be able to seek relief. However, the list of eligible offenses “was enacted as part of the same legislation that… declares custodial sexual misconduct as a sex offense” requiring registration as a sex offender. Id. Further, “[t]he Legislature is presumed to be aware of existing law and judicial interpretation when it adopts a statute.” Carson v. City of Prichard, 709 So. 2d 1199, 1206 (Ala. 1998). Therefore, the Alabama Supreme Court did not find Matthews’s argument valid under Alabama law.

Under Alabama law, custodial sexual misconduct requires an individual to register as a sex offender. However, this outcome is problematic. The Alabama Supreme Court made the correct decision based on a technicality; one it was compelled to follow due to the plain language of the statute enacted by the state legislature. Unless a law is unconstitutional, the Court does not have the power, and should not exercise the authority, to override it. In this case, the Court acted within its proper bounds and should not be criticized. The criticism should instead be directed at the legislature.

Sexual misconduct and custodial sexual misconduct are similar offenses. If one is eligible for relief from registration, the other should be as well. Matthews did not rape anyone, did not have sex with a minor, and, as she asserted, poses no risk to the public. There is no rational basis for subjecting her to the same restrictions as someone who poses a danger to children. Matthews should be held accountable for her offense but branding her with the lifelong stigma of being a registered sex offender is a cruel punishment for a crime in which, ultimately, she was the only victim.

If you have a Federal Criminal case, a State Criminal case, a Municipal Case or a Family Law case, contact Joe Ingram or Joe Joe Ingram Law, LLC at 205-335-2640. Get Relief Get Results.

articles

Blogs

1 / 44
Custodial Sexual Misconduct and The Sex Offender Registry

Custodial Sexual Misconduct and The Sex Offender Registry

Charged with custodial sexual misconduct in Alabama? Learn how a conviction can put you on the sex offender registry, what recent court cases mean for your future, and why legal reform is urgently needed.

read articles
Enforcing Arbitration Agreements Against a Third Party

Enforcing Arbitration Agreements Against a Third Party

Learn how Alabama law treats arbitration agreements in estate litigation. Discover when third parties—like executors—can be bound by a decedent’s arbitration clause.

read articles
When Can A Police Officer Use Deadly Force?

When Can A Police Officer Use Deadly Force?

Learn when a police officer can legally use deadly force under the Fourth Amendment. Explore key court rulings and constitutional standards in this high-profile Eleventh Circuit case.

read articles
Clearing Your Record in Alabama: What You Need to Know About Expungement

Clearing Your Record in Alabama: What You Need to Know About Expungement

Learn how to expunge a criminal record in Alabama. Discover eligibility rules, filing steps, costs, and how expungement can give you a fresh start. Get expert legal help.

read articles
HB247 Lulu’s Law: Irrational, But Beautiful

HB247 Lulu’s Law: Irrational, But Beautiful

Discover how Alabama’s Lulu’s Law established a shark attack monitoring and emergency alert system for the state’s coastal counties. Learn why this unique legislation, inspired by community advocacy after a tragic incident, reflects the power of local voices in shaping state policy. Explore the case’s impact, legislative background, and what it means for public safety on Alabama beaches.

read articles
Right to Counsel: When has this right been breached?

Right to Counsel: When has this right been breached?

Understand when the constitutional right to counsel applies in criminal cases. Learn from the recent Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals decision in Russell v. State about the critical stages where legal representation is required.

read articles
Can Prison Sentence Reductions Cross State Lines

Can Prison Sentence Reductions Cross State Lines

Discover whether prison sentence reductions can transfer across state lines. Learn about a key 2025 Alabama case that clarifies how correctional incentives apply when inmates move between states.

read articles
When is evidence sufficient to revoke probation?

When is evidence sufficient to revoke probation?

Learn when evidence is sufficient to revoke probation, based on a key 2025 Alabama court ruling. Understand the role of hearsay, probation violations, and legal standards in probation revocation cases.

read articles
Restitution and Evidence: When Is There Enough Evidence For Restitution

Restitution and Evidence: When Is There Enough Evidence For Restitution

Learn when restitution orders are legally valid under Alabama law. Discover why evidence and a proper hearing are essential before courts can require repayment to victims in criminal cases.

read articles
Understanding Cybercrime Charges and Digital Defense Strategies

Understanding Cybercrime Charges and Digital Defense Strategies

Facing cybercrime allegations? Learn the types of cybercrime charges, potential penalties, and how Joe Ingram Law LLC builds strong digital defense strategies. Summary Description: Explore how Joe Ingram Law LLC defends against cybercrime allegations with expert knowledge of digital forensics, hacking laws, identity theft, and data breaches.

read articles
The Interplay Between Plea Agreements and Aggravating Factors

The Interplay Between Plea Agreements and Aggravating Factors

Attorney Teresa Darwin Phillips pleaded guilty to theft, deception, and elder exploitation in Alabama. Learn how her failure to pay restitution impacted her sentencing and why the court upheld late notice of aggravating factors.

read articles
Running From The Cops: When is it 3rd Degree Felony Escape?

Running From The Cops: When is it 3rd Degree Felony Escape?

Facing charges for running from the police? Learn when fleeing becomes third-degree felony escape in Alabama and how recent court rulings may affect your case.

read articles
HB49’s Deadly Challenge Against the Supreme Court

HB49’s Deadly Challenge Against the Supreme Court

Alabama’s HB49 challenges Supreme Court precedent by proposing the death penalty for child rape. Learn how this controversial bill could reshape capital punishment law nationwide.

read articles
Default Judgment Divorce in Alabama: How Can You Avoid It?

Default Judgment Divorce in Alabama: How Can You Avoid It?

Learn how a default judgment in divorce can leave you with nothing if you don’t respond to legal filings. Discover how one Alabama court reversed such a judgment—and why immediate legal action is critical to protect your rights.

read articles
Appellate Courts: Arbiters of Justice

Appellate Courts: Arbiters of Justice

Explore how the justice system safeguards fairness through appellate review in United States v. Gregory, a federal drug trafficking case that reveals key protections for defendants and the power of appeals in correcting trial court errors.

read articles
David Eugene Files and the Interplay of Ethics and Jurisdiction

David Eugene Files and the Interplay of Ethics and Jurisdiction

In a case that made its way to the highest level of the state court system, the Alabama Supreme Court recently presided over an appeal beginning in Walker County. This case, Ex parte David Eugene Files, centers around a Rule 32 petition for postconviction relief. Files’ petition was dismissed by the Walker circuit court, with the dismissal being affirmed by the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals.

read articles
Sufficiency of Evidence: Reviewing the Admissibility and Application of Evidence Through US v. Mapson

Sufficiency of Evidence: Reviewing the Admissibility and Application of Evidence Through US v. Mapson

In a decision that affirms the admissibility and sufficiency of several distinct types of evidence, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit recently presided over an appeal that found its roots in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Alabama.

read articles
Are Courts Always Free to Divide Property in a Divorce?

Are Courts Always Free to Divide Property in a Divorce?

How courts divide real property in a divorce. Learn more from Ingram Law, LLC.

read articles
Till Death Do Us Part: Marital Property Division on Behalf of an Estate

Till Death Do Us Part: Marital Property Division on Behalf of an Estate

In a case that demonstrates the limits of alimony awards, the Alabama Court of Civil Appeals recently heard the case of Larry Shearry v. Christy Spivey, as personal representative of the Estate of Charlotte Shearry.

read articles
Fultondale Alabama Municipal Courts: Charges, Penalties, and Why You Should Seek an Attorney

Fultondale Alabama Municipal Courts: Charges, Penalties, and Why You Should Seek an Attorney

You are driving home late between the hours of 10:00 p.m. and 3:00 a.m. You get pulled over because the police officer states you are driving over the line, driving too slow, have a head light out or you have a taillight out.

read articles
latest-news

The Crime of Stalking in Alabama

Another category of criminal offense in Alabama is stalking. Covered by Article 5, stalking includes offenses for stalking in the first and second degree, aggravated stalking in the first and second degree, and electronic stalking in the first and second degree.

read articles
Navigating the Division of Marital Property: Lessons from Barbara Brown v. Ernest Brown

Navigating the Division of Marital Property: Lessons from Barbara Brown v. Ernest Brown

In a case that demonstrates the intricacies of equitable division of marital property, the Alabama Court of Civil Appeals recently presided over an appeal from the Jefferson Circuit Court in Jefferson County. The case of Barbara Brown v. Ernest Brown illustrates the importance of maintaining a clear record on appeal and emphasizes the necessity of full disclosure when dividing marital assets.

read articles
Navigating Legal Challenges; Brett Yeiter’s Fight Against a Death Sentence

Navigating Legal Challenges; Brett Yeiter’s Fight Against a Death Sentence

In a case illustrating the tumultuous and complicated proceedings for challenging a death sentence, the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals recently heard the appeal of Brett Richard Yeiter v. State of Alabama, stemming from Escambia County. Yeiter’s case underscores the critical need to adhere to procedural requirements, especially in cases involving severe sentences.

read articles
latest-news

Trademark Infringement: Causes of Action Under the Lanham Act

Federal trademark law is primarily governed by the Lanham Trademark Act, also referred to as the Trademark Act of 1946. The Lanham Act, codified in 15 U.S.C. §§1051 to 1127, covers a wide range of trademark issues including registration, maintenance, protection, and the creation of a federal cause of action for trademark infringement.

read articles
Navigating the Complexities of Marital Property Division: Catherine S. Cauthen v. Carey Lee Cauthen, Jr.

Navigating the Complexities of Marital Property Division: Catherine S. Cauthen v. Carey Lee Cauthen, Jr.

In a case that highlights the complex issues of marital property division during divorce proceedings, the Alabama Court of Civil Appeals recently heard the appeal of Catherine S. Cauthen v. Carey Lee Cauthen, Jr. Arising from Baldwin County, this case addresses the appeals of both the husband and the wife, demonstrating the intricate nature of property classification and division through six main points of contention. If you need a Divorce Lawyer, Please contact us about your case.

read articles
The Battle for Exoneration: Charles McCrory and the Fight Against Outdated Scientific Evidence

The Battle for Exoneration: Charles McCrory and the Fight Against Outdated Scientific Evidence

In a case that highlights broader systemic issues in the American justice system, the United States Supreme Court recently declined to review a controversial Alabama murder conviction. At this stage, the case of McCrory v. Alabama has been tumultuous for a man who continues to maintain his innocence. The increasing public attention directed towards the challenges defendants face when seeking exonerations is creating legislative pressure for reform, offering hope for a more just future.

read articles
latest-news

Pretrial Matters in Federal Court: How to Make Bond, Detention Hearings, and other Pretrial Functions

18 U.S.C. §3154 describes the functions and powers relating to pretrial services. The statute includes 14 particular functions, and a broader clause allowing the performance of any other functions specified under the chapter.

read articles
latest-news

The Interplay Between Lesser-Included Offenses and Double Jeopardy: The Case of R.E.F. v. State of Alabama

In a case that provides important clarification about double jeopardy when certain charges were reduced to their lesser-included offenses, the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals recently presided over the appeal of R.E.F. v. State of Alabama.

read articles
The Time Limit of Jurisdiction: Insights from Ex Parte State of Alabama

The Time Limit of Jurisdiction: Insights from Ex Parte State of Alabama

In a case that clarifies the bounds of jurisdiction for mandamus petitions, the Alabama Court of Appeals recently heard an appeal arising from Mobile County. This case, Ex Parte State of Alabama, explores trial court jurisdiction time limits without a stay, defining when new judgments can be issued, and orders enforced.

read articles
The Child’s Best Interest: The Two-Prong Test for Parental Termination

The Child’s Best Interest: The Two-Prong Test for Parental Termination

In a case that illustrates the high bar for terminating parental rights in child custody matters, the Alabama Court of Civil Appeals recently presided over an appeal arising from Baldwin County. This case, W.C.M. v. M.P., addresses a mother’s efforts to terminate the father’s parental rights, highlighting the complex and sensitive nature of proceedings seeking extreme legal remedies.

read articles
180 Years: Analyzing the Appeal of Travis Eugene Wolfe

180 Years: Analyzing the Appeal of Travis Eugene Wolfe

In a case addressing multiple facets of criminal procedure, the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals recently presided over an appeal from DeKalb County. This case, Travis Eugene Wolfe v. State of Alabama, demonstrates the breadth of trial court discretion when compounding consecutive sentences, while exploring the procedural and evidentiary requirements forming the basis for Wolfe’s conviction.

read articles
Drug Crimes in Alabama Both State and Federal Charges

Drug Crimes in Alabama Both State and Federal Charges

In Alabama, drugs are everywhere, both recreational and illegal. Drug charges carry significant jail time for distribution and trafficking, Alabama also criminalizes a wide array of drug offenses. Drug possession and sale offenses are covered by §13A-12-210 to §13A-12-219 of the Alabama Code.

read articles
Evidence of Prejudice: Joseph Michael Wilson and the Importance of Supporting Both Prongs of the Strickland Test

Evidence of Prejudice: Joseph Michael Wilson and the Importance of Supporting Both Prongs of the Strickland Test

In a case highlighting the extensive requirements to succeed under a Rule 32 petition, the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals recently presided over an appeal arising from Madison County. This case, Joseph Michael Wilson v. State of Alabama, illustrates the high evidentiary bar that criminal defendants must meet when alleging prejudice arising from ineffective assistance of counsel, demonstrating the high level of deference courts give to attorneys when determining trial strategy.

read articles
latest-news

Mens Rea: The Importance of Proving Intent In a Criminal Case

If you have a Federal Criminal case, a State Criminal case, a Municipal Case or a Family Law case, contact Joe Ingram or Ingram Law LLC at 205-335-2640.

read articles
latest-news

Rape And Sex Crimes in Alabama

Alabama law criminalizes a variety of sexual offenses, the most severe charges being for rape and sodomy. Charges for rape and sodomy in Alabama are classified based on the degree of the offense. Rape in the first degree and sodomy in the first degree, governed by §13A-6-61 and §13A-6-63 respectively, are both classified as Class A felonies.

read articles
latest-news

Fraud In a Divorce: Ex parte Gage Bruce Roberts

In a case that clarifies the court’s power to address acts of fraud, the Alabama Court of Civil Appeals recently presided over an appeal originating in Mobile County. This case, Ex parte Gage Bruce Roberts, addresses fraud in the context of a divorce judgment, emphasizing the court’s authority to handle such scenarios.

read articles
latest-news

Constitutional Standing and Proof of Intent: The Case of Johnnie Leeanozg DavisConstitutional Standing and Proof of Intent: The Case of Johnnie Leeanozg Davis

In a case that clarifies several principles of criminal procedure, the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals recently presided over an appeal arising from the United States District Court for the Middle District of Alabama.

read articles
Double Jeopardy in a Single Trial: The Case of Altonio Spencer

Double Jeopardy in a Single Trial: The Case of Altonio Spencer

In a case that illustrates the interplay of Alabama’s sentencing laws, the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals recently heard an appeal originating in Mobile County. This case, Altonio Spencer v. State of Alabama, explores the proper application of the Habitual Felony Offenders Act and clarifies the Double Jeopardy Clause’s applicability when one conviction is included within another.

read articles
latest-news

Federal Sex Crimes: Offenses, Penalties, and SORNA

18 U.S.C. Pt I, Ch. 109A covers federal sexual abuse crimes. Sexual abuse, codified in §2242, criminalizes three types of conduct. First, the section criminalizes using threats or fear to coerce another person to engage in a sexual act.

read articles
Definitions: Exploring the Effect of Statutory Language on Protection Orders

Definitions: Exploring the Effect of Statutory Language on Protection Orders

In a case that dives into evidentiary standards and proper applications of the law, a case arising from Lee County recently made its way to the Alabama Court of Civil Appeals. In the case of P.T.S. III v. S.S., the Court reviewed an elder-abuse protection order, clarifying evidentiary requirements and addressing the relevance and applicability of the Elder Abuse Protection Order and Enforcement Act.

read articles
latest-news

Sex Crimes And Computer Crimes in Alabama

Sexual Offenses are also recognized based on their relationship to technology. §13A-6-111 criminalizes transmitting obscene materials to a child by computer, classifying the crime as a Class B felony.

read articles
latest-news

Concurrent Split Sentences: Interpreting Sentencing Guidelines in Alabama Criminal Cases

In a case that clarifies the permissibility of concurrent split sentences, the Supreme Court of Alabama recently presided over the case of Ex parte Courtney Rayshun Elston.

read articles
Revocation Procedure: The Delicate Relationship Between Criminal Procedure and Due Process

Revocation Procedure: The Delicate Relationship Between Criminal Procedure and Due Process

The Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals recently presided over an appeal from Marion County, affirming the enduring significance of procedural rights in revocation proceedings. This case, Brandon Colby Hayes v. State of Alabama, clarifies the procedural necessity of a formal revocation hearing for community-corrections placements, thereby extending the policy for probation revocation in this area.

read articles
latest-news

THCA: The Unaddressed Cannabinoid in Federal Hemp Legislation

Six years ago, the Hemp Farming Act of 2018 went into effect as federal law, legalizing certain marijuana derivatives as “hemp.”

read articles

schedule a consultation

Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo
Joe Ingram Law Logo

Your path to get the right compensation starts here.